Environmental Press # 217

Subj: LATIMES: Steve Lopez slams Gabrieleno/Tongva
Date: Thu, 10 Apr 2003 18:29:59 -0700
From: Doug <doug@seal-beach.org>
To: voiceforveterans@aol.com (via SaveTheOaks@SealBeach.org)

RE: STEVE LOPEZ HATCHET JOB ON TONGVA IN L.A. TIMES

Hi,

In the long history of oppression visited upon our local Native Americans, the Gabrieleno/Tongva, it is common to see not only killing, but blaming the victims for the killing. Accounts from the 19th Century show angry Euros berating the Tongva while literally tearing them apart.

Now, the Los Angeles Times appears to join this criminal game via the column of one Steve Lopez in a facetious, derogatory article trying to associate the legitimate Gabrieleno/Tongva with a latter-day gambling entrepreneur.

Lopez, in the worst traditions of shoddy journalism, used one cursory quote from Chief Anthony Morales, and then got his story from the warped words of a non-Tongva gambling buff, whose "tribe" is on the 5th floor of a Santa Monica hi-rise.

 

 

Did Lopez know that the Gabrieleno/Tongva were approached by this "impressario", and literally chased him out because he wanted to cheapen their cultural revival with his sordid gambling aspirations?

No, Lopez failed to determine this crucial fact.

Did Lopez find out about the late and honored elders, who worked for decades to navigate the odious mechanism of the Bureau of Indian Affairs, trying to get federal educational and health care benefits that would be due the Gabrieleno/Tongva if they were able to compete for them, by achieving "federal recognition"?

Did Lopez inquire about the grants, about how Hon. Rep. Hilda Solis introduced HR2619, about how hard the Tribe worked to get the bill out of Hansen's committee, about how the chances for the bill were killed by this non-Tongva "impressario" approaching lawmakers and bragging about how much money he could spend on
lobbying for gambling? How it killed the bill? How the Tongva are now back to square one in being "recognized"? How the ancestors, of all factions, must weep over this setback, this smear?

No, Lopez failed to find this out.

Did Lopez imagine that the Tongva dancers, during their appearance at Kuruvungna this year, a sacred spring saved by the hard work of Tom Hayden and Marvin Braude, a crucial part of the cultural revival of ceremonial dance, were served with a frivolous lawsuit by the "impressario" and his minions?

No, Lopez blundered on, relying on the words of the false gambling "impressario", defaming and slandering, in my opinion, the honorable and long-suffering Tongva. Yes, the "impressario" has recruited 4 legitimate Tongva for his evil schemes, but perhaps they will now reconsider and rejoin the rest of the Tribe, and all its factions, in opposition to the "impressario".

Steve Lopez comes up with many more false impressions, unfortunately, retailing them in the pages of the L.A. Times.

You will see one of the many benefits the Gabrieleno/Tongva offer to all of us in the current "Treepeople" magazine, where the importance of the Tongva Dancers and their free performances is featured. But only one of many dozens of laudatory references to the real aims of the Tribe to revive their culture, almost wiped out by the Mission period, by the incursions of 1848-1851, by Indian Indenture, by the long period in which being known as Indian was to put your very life at risk.

What other people would put their own pain aside to share their rich and maligned culture, their native plant lore, their reverence for the land, their respect for sacred places and their ancestors?

Instead of finding out about the people and culture that went before, that still care for the land, Lopez sneers that the Tongva are reduced to perhaps only 400 members. If he only knew how difficult it was for those few to survive, and revive their culture.

Lopez is not alone in his ignorance. 50 years in the Los Angeles area still leaves many of us ignorant of the people who belong here, who lived here for thousands of years. If it had not been for the Tongva such as Chief Morales, Mark Acuna, Linda Gonzalez, Angie Behrens, and so many other generous, helpful Tongva and Acjachemen, I too would have remained ignorant of these cultural values. The only reason I found out was when the Tongva fought so hard to protect their sacred graves on top of the hellman mesa in Seal Beach.

Every week, teachers write to the Tongva, asking for more information, so that school children can learn about this hidden history, and learn about a truly mature and wise -- and forgiving -- people who have a lot to offer all of us.

You can write to Steve Lopez:
Steve.Lopez@latimes.com
Call the Oped pages at 213-237-2121 or 213-237-7939
Send a letter of protest to the L.A. Times,
asking that Lopez tell the other side of the story,
letters@latimes.com

Sincerely,

Doug Korthof (not a Tongva)
1020 Mar Vista
Seal Beach, CA 90740-5842
562-430-2495
email doug@seal-beach.org
cell:714-496-1567

The highland now known as Seal Beach was close to the legendary village of Puvungna, located where Cal State Long Beach is now. Puvungna was the center of origin of a system of rites and ceremonies influential throughout what is now Southern California. The estuary of the great San Gabriel River was at the heart of trading
activities of the ancient Tonva, who sailed up and down the coast and to offshore islands in their great plank Ti'at canoes. The land of the Tongva stretched from the Chumash and Tataviam in the north to the Acjachemen in Orange County. You can see a map on http://Tongva.com. Ancient ceremonial burial sites in Seal Beach were desecrated by John Laing Homes on the former Hellman Rancho, home to at least 11 ORA sites. The state Native American Heritage Commission has designated Chief Anthony Morales as the "Most Likely Descendant" in charge of the ceremonial reburial and ritual honor due these ancestors who, the Tongva believe, were disturbed on their journey through the spirit world. This is only one of many sacred sites of the Tongva and Acjachemen that are threatened or which have already been violated by rampant, unchecked over-development that also threatens formerly rich wildlife habitat and wetlands. Thanks in large part to the Tongva, the Seal Beach Wetlands were saved (left bank of the San Gabriel, part of the Los Cerritos Wetlands complex).

Back to T.O.C. 3