Environmental Press # 253

Subj: Water and waste...and more
Date: Sun, 25 May 2003 20:30:45 -0700
From: Doug Korthof <doug@seal-beach.org>
To: voiceforveterans@aol.com (via list)

1. Best beaches are not in OC
2. Attend OCSD 5:00 P.M. Wed., May 28 oppose sewagers
3. Important RMV workshop 6:30 P.M. Wed., May 28
4. Attend OCSD 7:00 P.M. Wed., May 28 support Board decision to end waiver
5. CSUFullerton bulldozes stream, may lose Modjeska refuge
6. Desert opened to tens of thousands of off-road carousers
7. Coastal Commission discovers some permits don't get followed
8. Forest protections significantly weakened -- only the start

---------------------------------------------------------
1. Dr. Stephen Letterman ranked the 10 best beaches (based on sand and water quality, temperature, absence of litter and balance of nature and artifacts):
01. Kaanapali Beach (HI)
02. Fort DeSoto Park (FL
03. Ocracoke Island (NC)
04. Hanalei Bay (HI)

 

05. Caladesi Island State Park (FL)
06. Main Beach in East Hampton (NY)
07. Makalawena Beach (HI)
08. Hanauma Bay (HI)
09. Cape Florida State Park (FL)
10. Cape Hatteras (NC).
(NOTE: "sewer city" is not on the list! Could it be dead fecal debris drifting back to shore through a mostly lifeless near-shore Ocean...)

-------------------------------------------------
2. Wed., May 28, 5PM: OCSD Steering Meeting 10844 ELLIS AVE, HB
4. Wed., May 28, 7PM: OCSD Board Meeting 10844 ELLIS AVE, HB

The Orange County Sanitation District (OCSD) voted to end reliance on an embarrassing "waiver" that allowed OC to be the largest dumper of live bacteria-laden fecal sewage solids in the USA. Thanks to public scrutiny of the secretive District.

The habit of secrecy, fostered by public neglect and lack of adequate supervision, is said to have bred complacency and arrogance into an ugly mix with deferred maintenance and steadfast refusal to provide for upgrading the plant in tune with the increasingly urban character of once-farmed O.C.

Some OCSD Directors, and the primordial Orange County Register, are fiercely opposed to any environmental cleanup that is not directly visible from their lofty perches.

SEWAGE SCOFFLAWS STRIKE BACK

Yorba Linda Director Mike Duvall, one of those who fought bitterly against cleaning up the discharges, inserted a potential monkey-wrench into OCSD plant modernization. Instead of gradually raising rates, as had been planned, to about $200 per year (from
the current $87), Duvall et al proposed raising the rates to $220 in the next 5 years, PRIOR to the upgrade to full secondary standards.

This dramatic, sudden increase is being exploited by the OCRegister to raise popular outrage at the decision to upgrade. Confusingly, secondary only accounts for 20% of the proposed increase, yet it is being blamed for all of it.

WHY NOT USE THE "RESERVES"?

The problem might be that the plant cannot really be upgraded to secondary without first completing about $1.8 BILLION in other deferred repairs. Perhaps some really basic fixes must be done before the possibility of upgrading to secondary standards is
even possible. Secondary, by itself, only costs about $450m, only about 20% of the cost of proposed upgrades.

Otherwise, the public might ask, WHY jack up rates to raise $450 million, if OCSD really HAS $554,000,000 in "reserves"? Instead of bumping up rates, spend the "reserves", that would divert public anger. If they really have the cash. The question arises, DOES OCSD HAVE THE MONEY? Perhaps a crusading newspaper would call for a full audit of OCSD, which seems overdue. There are claims that OCSD may not have
strictly followed the new standard GSB34. In addition, an ongoing internal audit might help restore public confidence.

Blaming the relatively small portion of the increase on the move to secondary seems unfair. Perhaps this makes big headlines and raises some opposition.

Please attend the dual meetings ("steering committee" at 5PM, Board at 7PM) and support the move to full secondary standards. Taking care of our own waste materials seems inescapeable, and everyone should be willing to pay what is necessary.

Even more important, we need new waste treatment ideas. We are using the basic old Roman plumbing method -- flush out the vomitorium with water floating in via aqueduct, and dump it in the sea -- that worked 2500 years ago.

Each person requires 200 gallons per day of potable water, and generates 100 gallons per day of waste water. Doing the math, this cannot go on forever. San Diego is in the situation of not having adequate supplies of fresh water, and not having made adequate provision for wastewater reclamation.

OCSD: BAD CASE OF CONSTIPATED MAINTENANCE AUDIT OCSD: WHERE'S THE $554,000,000 RESERVES $554 MILLION CASH RESERVES: WHERE'S THE MONEY USE 500 MILLION RESERVES, DON'T RAISE OUR RATES $554 MILLION RESERVES: USE IT, IF YOU HAVE IT $554 MILLION "RESERVES": DO THEY HAVE THE MONEY? THE WORST, THE MOST, THEY'RE DUMPING ON THE COAST

Also, please OPPOSE item 13m, Shea Homes (Near Los Patos and Bolsa Chica) annexed to OCSD. This bails them out, and NO new sewer connections should be allowed until we treat existing sewage to the minimum secondary treatment level.

--------------------------------------------------
2. Wed., May 28, 6:30-9:30: Rancho Mission Viejo SAMP workshop (simultaneous with OCSD meeting)
San Juan Capistrano Community Center
25925 Camino Del Avion,
San Juan Capistrano

DIRECTIONS: PCH south past Dana Point, turn left on Del Obispo (just before 5 FWY), proceed to Camino Del Avion, turn right, make a left into the Community Center.

US Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS), Fish and Game (DFG), US Army Corps of Engineers (ACE), and OCPlanning (BARF) are holding a PUBLIC WORKSHOP to allow opponents of the Rancho Mission Viejo (RMV) mega-development to rant and rave. After hundreds oppose development, the "buros" will move closer to approving the Special Area [mis-]Management Plan (SAMP) and Natural Communities Conservation Plan/Habitat Conservation Plan (NCCP/HCP) that allows them to evade strict compliance with the National Environment Protection Act (NEPA) and Endangered Species Act (ESA).

This is the time to bring a new perspective to bear on stopping this -- and dozens of other -- proposed housing tracts on top of virgin land and critical habitat.

New regulations require that housing tracts show where the huge new quantities of fresh water will come from (everyone just seems to assume that there is no limit to how much sewage OCSD can agree to handle). For each 10,000 new residents, 2,000,000 gpd of fresh water are needed.

Municipal Water District (MWD) and other primary water distributors cannot show where this water is coming from.

ENTER DESALINATION

Despite the bad economics that led to the idling of the Catalina and Santa Barbara desal plants, the rap is that unlimited supplies of fresh water could be provided by desal plants. The important point to remember is that the cost is high. Only the concept of "blended cost" of higher-priced (ultra-pure) desal water mixed in with cheaper, mineral-laden groundwater allows even mild plausibility.

The other important point to remember is that actual delivery of the new water is not necessarily guaranteed.

There seems no bar to full permitting of the desal plant, since at this point there is no actual agreement to increase population density. There is a vague intent to supply new tracts, but not enough evidence to derail desal based on fostering growth.

Should the desal plant agree to supply water to MWD, or Rancho Santa Margarita Water District, that might close the door to arguments that they don't have the water. The desal water, it can be argued, is not "paper" water, the plant is on the way. If it should prove uneconomical, and close, well, that would just be another challenge! The hillsides would be graded, the Oaks destroyed, the new houses built and sold. Picking up the pieces is a job for the ever-suffering Taxpayer.

Hence, NOT stopping the desal plant might be a big mistake for RMV opponents (and also Saddlecreek/crest, Saddleback Meadows, RMV, Bolsa Chica Mesa upper bench [having trouble getting well water from Cypress]).

Conversely, STOPPING DESAL plant might require a lot of marginally viable projects to reconsider their mandate. This might even give pause to the powerful forces ramming Rancho Mission Viejo through the permit process.

-------------------------------------------------------------
5. Cal State Fullerton may lose Tucker Wildlife Sanctuary
http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-sanctuary24may24,1,4999219.story
CSUF may have violated conditions of the gift, and Audubon may decide to seek a more responsible trustee. According to the story, CSUF graded a blue line stream without regulatory approvals, closed it without warning, and may be preparing for much higher human usage of the tiny (12 ac.) bird sanctuary at the end of Modjeska Canyon.

-------------------------------------------------------------
6. Bush opens dunes to vehicles
http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-dunes24may24,1,429991.story

BLM opened all but a small portion of the Imperial Sand Dunes to "recreational" vehicle use, despite fears that it will impact fragile desert habitat, life systems and endangered species such as the Desert Tortoise. If you know anything about how these people operate, there is not much to be said for this BLM action. Driving over the desert, dead drunk, playing "chicken" with other bigwheels, shooting at anything that moves, flinging beer bottles at paintballers...a fantasy? Perhaps.

-----------------------------------------------
7. UNDER OUR NOSE: Coastal Commission finds it's been snookered
http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-afford24may24,1,3099663.story

The Coastal Commission was at one time able to demand affordable housing as one component of Coastal projects. Those who took advantage of the reduced prices were supposed to live in the units for 20 years. Instead, it seems many just ignored this idea and illegally rented the units out for a profit, or just took their "gain" and sold the unit on the open market for a big profit. Well, the CCC found out. Now if only they would make sure that all those "offers to dedicate" were accepted by cities, and that all those decks they authorized are really built as permitted...

-----------------------------------------------------------------
FOR ALL THOSE WHO SUPPORTED THE JERK RALPH NADER, his dupes, and the repub collaborators who ran the whole thing: Criticize Clinton for not saving every tree, now deal with this!

8. In plan to speed logging in Northwest, sensitive species seen losing
http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/nation/la-na-forest24may24,1,7727857
.story

"Under proposed changes...forest managers would no longer have to survey for dozens of sensitive plant and animal species before logging. "The changes, prompted by a timber industry lawsuit..."

The technique here was for industry to sue, and the "Justice" department to "settle" in an agreement that would otherwise violate ESA and other laws. Perhaps embarrassment was the real reason EPA snake Whitman resigned.

The only thing left is for them to call it the "forest protection and habitat saving act of 2003". Freedom is slavery! Truth is falsity! The crazy immorality and perverse infamy of the Bush administration goes on and on. Clinton, they said, stole $200k on Whitewater; repubs spent $40 million investigating him. In the end, they got him on sexual flavors, which would, if truth be told, hang nearly every one of them (Nixon excepted) including Bush (whose dadddy, it is said, paid for the abortion for one of his jilted girlfriends, among other things).

Meanwhile, no one seems to object as we shoot over 1000 tons of low-level radioactive waste at Iraqi tanks, which, when incinerated as planned, creates clouds of radioactive dust, contaminating civilian kids. No one seems to notice that we unilaterally abrogated and denounced several treaties, as well as the authority of the U.N., and that we have taken over, apparently, two new satrapies for the unforseeable future. No one exclaims in wonder at the sleaze of it all, how California was punished by the electric deregulation scam, how they STOLE $30 BILLION OF OUR MONEY, and the connections to Cheney, Bush and Rove -- not peripheral connections, either. Cheney is still stonewalling release of his conferences with the
very companies ripping us off. No one is complaining about the lack of investigation of the so-called terrorist attacks on the world trade center -- why planes that routinely
scramble on a hijacking were not in the air -- why the hijackers allegedly came from Saudi.

The sleaze is getting deep around Washington, D.C.

The killing of the Clean Air Act, the Clean Water Act, Endangered Species Act...Well, maybe only weakening them, but Bush still has 5 years to go, if repub "dirty trix" operatives succeed, as now appears certain, to maneuver the weak Lieberman, pencil-neck geek, and the inept Kerry as the demo candidates.

Things will get progressively worse, in the next by and by.

/Doug

Back to T.O.C. 3