Environmental Press # 284

Subj: SB754 defeated by rogue Dems but granted "reconsideration"
Date: 7/16/2003 11:51:18 AM Pacific Daylight Time
From: doug@seal-beach.org
To: voiceforveterans@aol.com
Sent from the Internet (Details)

re: Assym. Wolk and Montanez killed the Heritage Tree bill for this year. It may be "reconsidered" next year.

Hi,

The Heritage Tree law, SB754, was DEFEATED on a vote July 7, 2003 due to the inaction of two Dems who sat on their hands through the vote. Their inaction killed the bill. Instead of passing, it failed.

The light of history has landed on the Dems. Dems have control of all committees in both houses. Dems have all statewide offices. To FAIL at this elementary piece of legislation means that some Dems have caved in and surrendered, means that, as a Party, the Dems "...have been tried in the balance, and found wanting...".

There is no excuse, no justification, no way to attone for those two errant quondam "Democrats".

 

On July 14, SB754 was granted "reconsideration", meaning that it can be brought back -- but no sooner than NEXT year. But next year may be too late. The Dems may have blown their chance.

This is very bad.

The two alleged Democrats who, essentially, killed the bill for this year voted in accordance with the bill opponents, not with the trees.

The two so-called Dems who sat down and let the bill die -- at least for this year -- are:

---
Montanez, Cindy: LET THE HERITAGE TREE BILL DIE THIS YEAR
District Office
11541 Laurel Canyon Boulevard, Suite C
Mission Hills, California 91345
Phone 818-838-3939 Fax 818-838-3931
Assy Office
P.O. Box 942849, Sacramento, CA 94249-0039
Phone: 916-319-2039 Fax: 916-319-2139
Email: Assemblymember.Montanez@assembly.ca.gov
Johanna or Janell in Assym. Montanez office stated that "she voted for reconsideration" the next week, and that "she felt she did not know enough about it" to vote.
---
Wolk, Lois: FAILED TO VOTE, LETTING THE HERITAGE TREE BILL DIE District Office
555 Mason Street, Suite 275, Vacaville, CA 95688
Phone 707-455-8025 Fax: 707-455-0490
Assy Office
State Capitol, Room 6012, Sacramento, CA 95814
Phone: 916-319-2008, Fax: 916-319-2108
Email: Assemblymember.Wolk@assembly.ca.gov
Craig Reynolds in Assym. Wolk's office was not available for comment on this story.
------------------------------------------

-----ADAPTED FROM AN ALERT BY THE CIRCLE OF LIFE
"...SB 754 has passed the California State Senate and is now moving in the California State Assembly...the logging industry is already lobbying Assembymembers, looking to kill the bill.
"...PLEASE take just one minute ... To find your Assemblymember's contact information, please go to http://www.ancienttrees.org and click on "Contact your Assemblymember." Phone, fax and/or write until you are sure that they will vote "Yes" on SB 754, The Heritage Tree Preservation Act...
"SB 754 will protect 'heritage' trees on non-federal forestland that were alive in 1850, marking the year of California's statehood and the onset of commercial logging. The trees must also meet species-specific diameter requirements. California has already lost 97% to 99% of its ancient trees, this bill will save the remaining 1% of trees on non-federal forestland that qualify for heritage protection. For more information on the Heritage Tree Preservation Act ... http://www.ancienttrees.org or call Lisa Beyer at 510-444-4710 ext. 308."
--------------------END ADAPTED MESSAGE

Note that SB754 is just the *first* step in the right direction of a series of necessary new laws:
--Much stronger Coastal Act. Can be strengthened by revision of key PRC sections, to plug loopholes and make the Coastal Act more vibrant on "Local Coastal Program" review, on watershed protections, and on stopping the armoring of the Coast and re-affirming public access as practical and necessary -- and preserving what little is left of the priceless Coastal rainforest-like diversity.
--No building on virgin land in California. Most people would rather not see the destruction of hillsides, lakes, etc., for private benefit housing tracts since they don't see themselves as buying one of the new houses, but can see themselves someday visiting the flowering habitat. All it takes is circulation of a statewide initiative to propose, and pass, such an initiative, which will end the viability of such projects as SaddleXXX and Rancho Mission Viejo.
--Revision of water resource policy. Conserve, reuse, source separation instead of our policy of getting water from, and dumping waste, "somewhere ELSE" that hearkens from days of the Roman aquaducts and vomitoria.

/Doug

REGISTERED SUPPORT (the good people):
Campaign for Old Growth (sponsor)
Audubon California
Bay Area Coalition for Headwaters
California Democratic Party Environmental Caucus
California League of Conservation Voters
California Oaks Foundation
Center for Biological Diversity
Defenders of Wildlife
Earth Island Institute
Environmental Protection Information Center
Forestry Monitoring Project
Forests Forever
Friends of the Eel River
Green Party of California
National Wildlife Federation
Planning and Conservation League
Sierra Club California
The Walden Woods Project
approx. 60 individuals

REGISTERED OPPOSITION TO THE BILL: ROGUES GALLERY
Applied Forest Management, LLC
Big Creek Lumber Company
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Forestry Association
California Licensed Foresters Association
Campbell Timberland Management
Collins Almanor Forest
Collins Lakeview Forest
Forest Products Industry National Labor Management Committee
Hancock Natural Resource Group, LLC
Harwood Products, Inc.
Howlett Ranch
Mailliard Ranch
Mendocino Redwood Company
Olympic Resource Management
Red River Forests Partnership
Roseburg Resources Company
Shasta Forests
Simpson Resource Company
W. M. Beaty & Associates, Inc.
2 individuals

Back to T.O.C. 3